How to become a 5-star rated business

There are a number of reasons why online ratings are important for your business. One of the most important is that online reviews are instrumental in building trust and credibility which, in turn, boosts sales and retention. 

Here’s a handy guide on establishing and maintaining a 5 star reputation for your business.

Step 1: Choosing the right online review platform

There are countless review platforms available, including Google, Trustpilot, Yelp, Facebook, Feefo, and G2. But trying to be everywhere at once can spread your efforts too thin and dilute your reviews. Instead, focus on the platforms that matter most to your audience.

• Google Business Profile – Ideal for most businesses types as it boosts SEO and pulls in ratings from other sources.
• Trustpilot – Great for eCommerce businesses due to integrations and trust-building features.
• G2 – Best for software and SaaS companies targeting B2B clients.
• Facebook Reviews – A powerful tool for local businesses and D2C brands looking to build social proof.

Not sure where to start? Research where your competitors are collecting reviews or ask customers where they look for business ratings.

Step 2: Deliver 5-star customer experiences

A simple truth: You can’t get great reviews without happy customers.

If you want a 5-star reputation, focus on creating outstanding customer experiences at every stage of the journey - before, during and after the sale.

Studies show that 80% of customers view experience as important as the product itself—if not more so. 

Key areas to focus on:

• Create a smooth customer journey - Ensure your buying process is easy, clear, and frustration-free
• Communication is key - Customers value quick responses, clear communication, and proactive support
• Fast and effective issue resolution – Mistakes happen, but handling them professionally can turn a negative experience into restored confidence

Step 3: Ask for reviews

Statistically, customers are more likely to leave a negative review than a positive one when unprompted. 

You’ll get far more success accumulating positive ratings when you simply ask for them. Here are some good ways to ask for positive reviews:

• Sending a follow-up email after purchase or service completion with a direct review link. You can use a CRM tool like Hubspot to easily automate post-sales emails
• Incentivise reviews (ethically) by offering discounts, loyalty points, or exclusive content
• Make it easy for your customers - The less effort the customer has to make to leave feedback, the more likely they are to complete the process. Direct links and QR codes are great for a quick, seamless process 

 Step 4: Don’t be scared of negative reviews

Sometimes things go wrong. Even the biggest businesses receive negative feedback - it’s how you handle it that matters most.

• Respond quickly and empathetically
• Offer a solution where possible
• Follow up with the customer directly to turn the situation around
• Learn from any mistakes

If all goes well, your customer may end up changing their review once a resolution is met. If not, others will see how you’ve responded, which can further build trust despite the circumstances.

‍

Want help building a 5* reputation?

Get in touch with our team:

Book a call

Pop us an email: hello@methodhq.co.uk

‍